| |
|
Chilling in its exposure of the shameless racism, class prejudice and cruelties of eugenic attitudes and practices in the United States... [Black's book] prompt[s] us to wonder what in medical genetics and biotechnology we are taking socially and morally for granted today that our descendants might indict us for tomorrow.
|
Daniel J. Kevles
New York Times Book Review |
| |
|
In War Against the Weak: Eugenics and America's Campaign to Create a Master Race, investigative journalist Edwin Black compellingly argues that the ethnic-cleansing movement that culminated in Nazi Germany's death camps during World War II was the realization of a particularly ugly American dream. Black, whose mother lived under Nazi rule in Poland, writes here with the zeal of an avenger, albeit one with the assistance of a team of 50 researchers who unearthed some 50,000 documents to support his case.
|
Gregory Mott
Washington Post Book World
Read Review |
| |
|
Edwin Black, author of the radical and revelatory IBM and the Holocaust, is a dangerous man. He tells us things we don't want to hear, like, for instance, this: "The scientific rationales that drove killer doctors at Auschwitz were first concocted on Long Island." His groundbreaking War Against the Weak, Eugenics and America's Campaign to Create a Master Race... is a scary and necessary book.
|
Adrienne Miller
Esquire Magazine
Read Review |
| |
|
Ambitious... richly detailed... [Black has] written a serious, thoroughly documented study. The scope of the book is impressive -- it spans 150 years and reaches into the archives of four countries -- and it contains some remarkable new data and sharp insights. ...Black has the right credentials to tear away the thickets of mystery surrounding the eugenics movement...the author brings a critical sensability to his work.
|
Tony Platt
Los Angeles Times Book Review |
| |
|
In a new book, War Against the Weak, investigative reporter Edwin Black makes the case that 20th Century American proponents of eugenics... had substantive ties to the architects of Hitler's racial extermination machine...Black lays bare the veins of collaboration between American eugenicists and Nazi scientists.
|
Dan Vergano
USA Today
Read Review |
| |
| ... the list of the morally culpable is long, stretching from Teddy Roosevelt to Winston Churchill, handily complicating the view of the Allied impact on the origins of World War II. Our devils lie in these contextual details, and we have some owning up to do. |
John Giuffo
Village Voice |
| Read Review |
| |
|
Black, aided by a small army of researchers and scholars, uncovers the roots of the Nazis' obsession with racial purity and their devotion to the Nordic ideal of blond hair and blue eyes, a notion popularized in the United States, not Germany. ...As we consider the commercial possibilities afforded by gene mapping, cloning and the like, this book should be required reading for leaders seeking to avoid the inevitable penalties bestowed upon those who fail to learn the lessons of history.
|
Richard Pachter
Miami Herald
Read Review |
| |
|
Fierce, compelling... well told and extraordinarily sad... a prodigious feat of reporting.
|
David Plotz
Mother Jones Magazine
Read Review |
| |
|
An important work... A well-documented, comprehensive exposition of a story not known to most Americans, about a perversion of the pursuit of knowledge in the interest of race and social superiority.
|
Steve Courtney
Hartford Courant
Read Review |
| |
|
Edwin Black has written what may well be the best book ever published about the American eugenics movement and the horrific events it spawned. Combining exhaustive research, a very readable style, and just the right touch of outrage, Black splendidly conveys the evil depth and breadth of eugenics philosophy, the pseudo-science and social theory that unleashed a half-century of war against society's most vulnerable citizens.
|
Wesley J. Smith
National Review
Read Review |
| |
|
In this bombshell of investigative journalism, Black (of IBM and the Holocaust) reveals that eugenics was extensive, systematic, well-funded, and supported by major political and intellectual leaders; perhaps most startling, it directly inspired the rise of Nazism in Hitler's Germany... This chilling and well-researched book is highly recommended.
|
Gregg Sapp
Library Journal |
| |
|
A hair-raiser and an eye-opener... contains details so vivid and horrid that one can hardly believe them or bear to read them.... This is an important book, filled with little-known facts about how some of our most esteemed institutions and professionals have funded and practiced very bad science, if it was science at all, and how this pseudoscience permeated much of the world's thinking and led to the atrocities of a world war.
|
Nancy Schapiro
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
Read Review |
| |
| What are the ethical, social and scientific implications of this potent new technology? In War Against the Weak, the investigative journalist Edwin Black lays bare the ugly story of Americas eugenics movement and cautions that with the arrival of a precocious new genetics age, a new war against the weak is imaginable. Blacks warningto separate fact from fantasy and blessings from menaces of 21st-century genetic engineeringis well worth heeding. Chilling reading...Black...has given us an astonishingly gripping narrative of the evils of eugenics. Especially in our postmodern world, this cautionary tale of distinct power elites describing people as leading a life unworthy of life is an important read. |
|
| |
|
Edwin Black's War Against the Weak is the best book on eugenics ever written.
|
American Bar Association
Appellate Practice Journal |
| |
Black- will definitely keep readers riveted to their chair. The chapter on "scientific" experiments conducted by Josef Mengele at concentration camps was particularly frightening... |
S. Jay Olshansky
Quarterly Review of Biology
Read Review
|
|
|
Did Auschwitz have its origins in America? Edwin Black argues that the "science" of eugenics was promoted by some of America's most important individuals and institutions, such as the Rockefeller Foundation, Oliver Wendell Holmes and even Woodrow Wilson. The author's descriptions of how 60,000 Americans were sterilized against their will in the name of racial purity will leave you speechless.
|
| Dallas Morning News |
| |
| Big Scary Book...Black's premise is that "the scientific rationales that drove killer doctors at Auschwitz were first concocted on Long Island at the Carnegie Institutions's eugenic enterprise at Cold Spring Harbor." |
Connie Ogle
Miami Herald |
| Read Review |
| |
|
Chilling and thoroughly researched... it is a book whose message must be made known... for those who say "It can't happen here."
|
Mark Lewis
Tampa Tribune |
| |
|
Fascinating... War Against the Weak is filled with tale after tale of arrogance, ignorance and cruelty—accounts that Black wisely allows the eugenicists to relate in their own words.
|
Carl Zimmer
Discover Magazine |
| |
| Edwin Black, the author of the award-winning IBM and the Holocaust: The Strategic Alliance Between Nazi Germany and America's Most Powerful Corporation, has written a provocative new book that traces the influence of the American eugenics movement on Nazi Germany. ...[War Against the Weak] is a valuable contribution to our understanding of the evolution of the Holocaust. |
Jack Fischel
Forward |
| Read Review |
| |
|
Impressive, probably the popular history of eugenics for the foreseeable future.
|
Ray Olson
Booklist |
| |
|
An impressive job... the resulting story is at once shocking and gripping... an important book that will add to the public's understanding of this critical chapter of American history.
|
| Publishers Weekly |
| |
| Mindblowing... Combining gripping narrative with corroborating facts and figures, Black connects the dots to what many know, at best, piecemeal: that the racist American pseudoscience of eugenics, pioneered in the first three decades of the 20th century, provided the basis of Hitler's quest for a so-called Master Race. Nor, even after the terrible lessons of the Holocaust, have we given up on a form of eugenics (now known as human genetics) to tinker with and attempt to improve humankind. |
Cynthia Dettelbach
Cleveland Jewish News |
| Read Review |
| |
| It’s easy to see why the Library Journal calls Edwin Black’s “War Against the Weak” a “bombshell of investigative journalism.” The facts gathered in it exhume a rank and shameful shadow history of American idealism.... The stuff of nightmares is between these overstuffed pages, stuff that has been exploited in horror films and science fiction. Here some of the creepiest parts of the X-Files are revealed as truth. ...Many moments in War Against the Weak shock. In fact, almost every detail read in short bits will chill your spine... Artists, writers, musicians -- take this book and present the kernels of this story in a form that will rip out the hearts of the audience. Because this story can, and should, rip out your heart. |
Jay Schwartz
The Jewish News Weekly of Northern California
Read Review |
| |
With each new twist, Black leaves the reader with ample evidence, culled from approximately 50,000 documents, and researched by 50 assistants in four countries, that horrible wrongs, in fact, occurred on American soil and might have played some role in casting events that led to the horrors of Nazi Germany... It may not always be easy reading, but certainly it is worthwhile, from beginning to end.
|
Michael Gartland
Charleston Post and Gazette
Read Review |
| |
| Edwin Black casts an unwelcome spotlight on an ugly time when American leaders and philanthropic institutions virtually created eugenics and sought to stop the "unfit" from reproducing. |
R. Cort Kirkwood
Harrisonburg Daily New-Record
Read Review |
| |
| Edwin Black's new book The War Against the Weak: Eugenics and America's Campaign to Create a Master Race is so timely. Black takes us back in depressing detail to the vast and enormously popular eugenics industry that caught the diseased imagination of the United States in the first part of the lst century... Read the book as, one hundred years later, we devise our strategy for the next round in the "war against the weak." Because we can be certain that the "Master Race" ideology, sophisticated in its science and rhetoric beyond the dreams of Homes and Hitler, is on its way. |
Nigel M. de S. Sameron
Council for Biotechnology Policy
Read Review |
| |
| In the development of personal conscience, we constantly re-evaluate our past. We examine the consequences of what we did, to determine what we will do. Edwin Black is an historian whose studies have focused on the Holocaust, perhaps because he is the son of Polish Holocaust survivors. Like all historians of the Holocaust, he has made it his work to remind us of things about ourselves we would rather not recall -- and must never forget. |
Anitra Freeman
Real Change News
Read Review |
| |
| Edwin Black chronicles, in considerable detail, the eugenics movement, presaging what ultimately happens in Nazi Germany (the latter eventually causing American proponents of the efforts to "purify" the population to cease their work). The book is a homily about social engineering, as well as racism, science, and statistics in our modern culture. |
Richard Cox
Records and Information Management Review
Read Review |
| |
| ... compelling read. Black's evidence and how he pieces it together portray another instance where misguided, crank science led to untold human misery;. |
Christopher Dreher
Pittburg Pulp
Read Review |
| |
| Edwin Black has conducted an extensive investigation... Black's style and sense of outrage are compelling. |
| Jewish Book World |
| |
In War Against the Weak, Edwin Black takes his ample research skills,
his captivating writing style and his firm moral compass to construct a
narrative of profound historical importance and contemporary relevance.
Black meticulously connects the US antecedents of the hideous policies
and practices of Nazism and goes a good way toward illustrating that
this was no mere perversion of an otherwise benign science, but a case
of taking a malign pseudo-science to its practical conclusion.
|
Howard A. Doughty
The College Quarterly
Read review |
| |
This is a chiing account of the development of the psuedoscience of euegnics and its ultimate effects....This book carries an important message about the use and misuse of scientific and social research. ...[Libraries should] buy this book. Put in on your shelves. Urge your patrons to study and ponder its contents.
|
JP Sanson
Choice Reviews for Academic Libraries
|
| |
|
This is an important book... [it] demonstrates the continuity
of attitudes only too well, and also the absence of a moral philosophy which explores
our right or duty to interfere with the natural processes of life. |
Paul Johnson
Sunday Telegraph
|
| |
|
Every once in a while you read a book that shifts the ground beneath you. Such a book is Edwin Black's War Against the Weak, which explodes the notion that the nightmares of Nazi Germany sprang full-blown from the disordered imagination of an Austrian house painter named Adolf Hitler. In this meticulously researched and powerfully narrated book, Black shows how the idea that an Aryan master race must perfect the human species by wiping out "inferior" peoples was first developed and articulated by the eugenics movement in the United States.
|
|
Daniel Bellow
|
|
Jerusalem Post
|
|
|
| |
|
Edwin Black's new book The War against the Weak: Eugenics and America's Campaign to Create a Master Race is so timely. Black takes us back in depressing detail to the vast and enormously popular eugenics industry that caught the diseased imagination of the United States in the first part of the lst century... Read the book as, one hundred years later, we devise our strategy for the next round in the "war against the weak." Because we can be certain that the "Master Race" ideology, sophisticated in its science and rhetoric beyond the dreams of Homes and Hitler, is on its way. |
| |
| Nigel M. de S. Sameron |
| Council for Biotechnology Policy |
| Read Review |
| |
|
A damning indictment of the racist, pseudo-scientific movement called eugenics.
|
| Andy Worthington |
| Nthposition.com |
| Read Review |
| |
In the stunning new book, War Against the Weak: Eugenics and America's
Campaign to Create a Master Race, investigative journalist Edwin Black... uncovers a long-repressed
chapter of social history significant enough to command reappraisal of the legacy of eugenics for today and
for the future. ... Edwin Black has distinguished himself as a journalist for more than two decades, both
in the United States and abroad. A masterpiece of research and style, War Against the Weak is
arguably his most important work to date and certainly one of the noteworthy books of the year. |
Vince Carducci
Popmatters.com
Read Review |
| |
You'll be floored by evidence of experiments in forced sterilization, human breeding programs,
marriage prohibition, and passive euthanasia — all seeking to eliminate non-white races, epileptics, alcoholics,
petty criminals, the mentally ill and others — a program sanctioned by our own Supreme Court. Black's treatment
of this historical elitism brings new implications to the Human Genome
Project and twenty-first century genetic engineering. |
| Speedreader |
| |
Eugenics is set for a come-back and will be the mother of all battles for the human race. Thats why Edwin Blacks new book The War against the Weak: Eugenics and Americas Campaign to Create a Master Race (New York: Four Walls, 2003) is so timely. Black takes us back in depressing detail to the vast and enormously popular eugenics industry that caught the diseased imagination of the United States in the first part of the last century.
|
| OrthodoxyToday.org |
| Read Review |
| |
| Meticulously researched and footnoted...Black leaves virtually no stone unturned in retelling the tale of this nations's eugenics movement. |
| Rick Giombetti |
| EatTheState.org |
| Read Review |
| |
| The plans of Adolf Hitler and the German Nazis to create a Nordic "master race" are often looked upon as a horrific but fairly isolated effort. Less notice has historically been given to the American eugenics movement of the 19th and early 20th centuries. Although their methods were less violent, the methodology and rationale which the American eugenicists employed, as catalogued in Edwin Black's Against the Weak, were chilling nonetheless and, in fact, influential in the mindset of Hitler himself. ... Black's detailed research into the history of the American eugenics movement is admirably extensive, but it is in the association between the beliefs of some members of the American aristocracy and Hitler that the book becomes most chilling. |
| John Moe |
| Amazon.com |
|
|
|
| |
| In pained, at times almost excruciating detail, Black creates a picture of the extent to which prominent figures in American life, ranging from Theodore Roosevelt to Margaret Sanger, along with such established American institutions as the Carnegie Institute and the Rockefeller Foundation, invested time, money, and prestige in the eugenics movement of the early twentieth century.
|
| Erika Nanes |
| Metapsychology Online |
| Read Review |
| |
Blacks book is a very black history of how the wealthy and powerful of the US attempted to control the racial groups and social classes they disliked and feared.
|
|
|